RAHNER: Love Beyond Death--What Now

Grief shows up like a power outage in the middle of ordinary life: the silence after the phone call, the empty chair, the moment you realize the world has kept moving while yours has split open.  We turn to theologian Karl Rahner for language that doesn’t flinch at that darkness or try to hustle you into feeling “better.” He offers a way to tell the truth about love, death, and the ache that follows.

Walk through Rahner’s view of the human person as “spirit in the world,” grounded in bodies and time yet always reaching beyond what any finite thing can satisfy. That restless longing, Rahner says, is a clue to God as holy mystery, the horizon beneath every question and every desire. From there, explore why grief is not an accident but a disclosure, how the “hole” left by someone you love is shaped like them, and why the depth of pain can reveal the depth of the bond. Rahner reframes death, not only as something that happens to us, but also as a final human act of self-surrender, and how that can invite real hope without pretending to provide certainty.

We also push back on the modern pressure to compress mourning into a neat timeline. Rahner helps us see lingering grief as fidelity, a witness that people are not interchangeable and love is real. Drawing on the via negativa, consider how grief can hollow us out and, if we resist the urge to numb it, become a place where God can be encountered without blaming God for suffering.

SPIRITUAL DIRECTION WHILE GRIEVING IS AVAILABLE :  candeelucas@soulplusgrace.com

ATTEND MY SUMMER WORKSHOP ON "SOULFUL LISTENING" THROUGH THE MARKEY CENTER AT SANTA CLARA UNIVERSITY VIA ZOOM.

https://events.scu.edu/markey-center/event/359741-soulful-listening-workshops-on-the-ministry-of

Art:  https://www.etsy.com/shop/vasonaArts?ref=seller-platform-mcnav
and  https://fineartamerica.com/profiles/candee-lucas

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0F2SFH4Z6

Music and sound effects today by:   via Pixabay

Transcript

Welcome And Purpose Of Solace

Candee 0:31

Welcome to Solace: Soul + Grief. I'm glad you're here. My name is Candee Lucas. I'm a Jesuit trained chaplain and spiritual director. When we started this ministry more than four years ago, our idea was to maintain a library of different grief topics so that you could find answers to questions you have from wherever you are in the grief process. You're always welcome in our circle of healing, love, and support. Karl Rahner was a German Jesuit priest and arguably the most influential twentieth century Roman Catholic theologian, instrumental in shaping the Second Vatican Council. He pioneered a modern, anthropocentric approach, emphasizing the innate human experience of God's grace. He wrote extensively about grief and loss, and today I would like to share a bit of his theology of loss. We all know grief. It usually arrives uninvited at the cemetery, in a hospital corridor, in the sudden silence of a house that used to be full of noise, and when it comes to us, we instinctively reach for something, comfort, explanation or meaning. We want someone to tell us why, and we want to know whether it will ever be okay again. Carl Rahner didn't offer cheap answers to these questions. What he offered was something harder and I think more honest. A theology that takes the darkness of grief seriously and finds within that very darkness the possibility of an encounter with God. Rahner was not a grief counselor. He didn't write a self-help book, he wrote profound theological manuals, which are dense and rich with God's presence. But woven through his dense philosophical theology is a vision of human existence that has profound things to say about loss and death and mourning. Today I want to draw those threads together and ask, what does Rahner's theology offer to a grieving person? To understand Rahner on grief we have to start where he starts with the human person. For Rahner, the human being is "Geist in Welt", translated spirit in the world. We are creatures who are simultaneously embedded in matter, in time, in bodies, and yet oriented toward the infinite. We are the beings who ask questions that the world cannot answer. We are the ones who hunger for a completeness that no finite thing can satisfy. This restlessness, this longing, this reaching beyond every horizon is not a bug, it's a feature. It is our deepest nature. Rahner calls this "Vorgriff auf", a pre-grasp of being itself, an orientation toward what he calls the holy mystery. Rahner was deeply influenced by Heidegger's concept of --Zeinzum Todo--, being toward death. We do not simply die at the end of life. We live always in the shadow of our own mortality. Death is not an event that happens to us at the conclusion of life, it is a dimension of every moment. Every love we form is formed in the knowledge, however suppressed, that it will end. Every joy contains within it the seed of its own loss. That is why grief for Rahner is not an accident or an interruption. It is a disclosure. When we grieve, we are brought face to face with what we normally keep at arm's length, the radical contingency of everything we love and of ourselves. Grief strips away the comfortable illusion that we are in control, that our loves are permanent, that our world is safe. This may sound bleak, but Rahner insists it is precisely here, in this stripping down that something essential can happen. One of Rahner's most powerful ideas is what he calls transcendental experience. This is not a dramatic, mystical event. It is the quiet, often unnoticed experience of being oriented beyond every finite thing. It happens whenever we love someone and sense that our love reaches beyond what the beloved can fully satisfy. It happens whenever we encounter beauty and feel a longing that no particular beautiful thing can quite fulfill. It happens whenever we pursue truth and discover that every answer opens into new questions. Rahner's claim is that this endless reaching, this dissatisfaction, as it were, with the finite, is itself an experience of God. Not God as an object we can see or touch, but God as the silent, encompassing horizon toward which all our longing moves. God is not one item in the world. God is the holy mystery that makes the world possible and draws us into it and beyond it. Now consider what grief does. When someone we love dies, a hole opens in our world. And that hole is not nothing. It is, as it were, shaped, shaped exactly like the person we have lost. The grief is somehow proportionate to the love. The depth of the wound tells us something about the depth of the bond. But Ronor would press further. It was a finite participation in a love that is infinite and encompassing. When we love another human being, we are, whether we know it or not, loving them in God and toward God. The bond that death severs is real, and the love that undergirded it is in no way destroyed. This is why Rahner can say in his remarkable essay on the death of a Christian that the dead are not simply absent, they have not gone "nowhere", they have entered more fully into God, who is not a remote being, but the innermost ground of all reality. The one we grieve is, in Rahner's vision, not less present, but differently present, hidden in the mystery that surrounds us on all sides. This does not dissolve or resolve the grief. Rahner never suggests that theology should do this, should accomplish this, but it reframes it. The ache of the absence is real, and it is pointing toward a reality that has not been annihilated. Rahner's theology of death is unusual and worth dwelling on. For many people and for much popular religion, death is something that happens to us. It is the enemy, the thief, the end. Rahner does not deny the darkness of death, but he insists that death is also for the human person an act. Throughout our lives we are engaged in the slow process of deciding who we will be, of freely disposing ourselves toward or away from God, toward or away from love, toward or away from the truth. This process of self determination happens in thousands of small choices. But Rahner argues that death brings this process to its completion. In death, the person makes a final, total self-surrender. The last defense is dropped. The illusion of self ends. And in that moment, the person either opens fully to the mystery, which is to say God, or closes against it. What does this mean for one who grieves? It means that the person we have lost was not passive in their dying. However confused or painful or sudden or drawn out their death was, their dying was also at some deep level, a human act, a final word spoken in freedom. Rahner invites us to trust that the person we love, in the depth of their dying, encountered the God toward whom their whole life has been moving, even if they never named it that way, even if they never called the journey such. This is a quietly revolutionary idea. It means that the most inarticulate, the most secular, the most apparently faithless death is not closed off from God. The holy mystery is not kept at bay by lack of church going. God meets the dying person in the most interior act of their existence. For the grieving person, this is not a proof or a certainty. It is an invitation to hope, a theological hope which is different from optimism an invitation to hope, a theological hope which is different from optimism. Optimism says things will probably work out. Hope says, even here, what looks like the end, I entrust this person to a love that does not let go. Rahner's theology does something else, I think, that is quietly important. It refuses to let grief be merely a psychological problem to be resolved. It treats grief as a spiritual experience, a place where we can encounter the deepest questions of human existence and potentially the deepest and most final answer. Modern culture, especially in the West, is profoundly uncomfortable with grief and mourning. We want it to follow a tiny arc, shock, sadness, acceptance, and then to end. We give people a few weeks of sympathy and then begin subtly, or not so subtly, to communicate. To outsiders, grief that lingers too long begins to look like a problem, a dysfunction, a failure to cope. Rahner pushes back against this not by arguing for grief, but by placing it within a larger context. The person who grieves is not failing, they are in their pain bearing witness to the truth that love is real, that persons are irreplaceable, and that the world without the beloved is genuinely lesser. To grieve fully is to honor the one who has died. It is to resist the lie that people are interchangeable and that loss is merely an adjustment. Moreover, Rahner's mystical theology suggests that grief, when lived through rather than suppressed, can become a moment of encounter with God. This is not because God causes suffering to teach us lessons. Rahner is way too sophisticated for that kind of theology. It is because the place where our self-sufficiency, where our "self" collapses, is exactly the place where we become open to what is beyond ourselves. Grief hollows us out. And in that in that hollowed and hallowed space, if we do not rush to fill it with noise and distractions, something can enter that was always there but could not get through. This is what the mystics have always known. The "via negativa", the way of negation, of letting go, of being stripped down to nothing, is not a punishment. It is a path. Rahner's theology of grief belongs in this tradition. The wound is real, and the wound can become an opening. I want to close with something Rahner wrote that has stayed with me. He said, --In the torment of the insufficiency of everything attainable, we learn that ultimately in this world there is no finished symphony. The music stops mid phrase. The conversation ends before everything has been said. The person leaves. The person is gone before the love has run its course. Because love doesn't run its course. It doesn't have one.-- That the person we lost is held in a mystery that does not discard what it has once embraced. And that our grief, born honestly and with faith, is itself a form of fidelity. To grieve is to love. To love is to reach toward the infinite. And the infinite, says Rahner, reaches back. The symphony is not finished here. We are living in the middle of it. And the one who composed it has not abandoned the score. That concludes another episode. A new one drops every Friday morning. This has been your host, Candee Lucas. Travel with God this week always at your side. Vaya con Dios.